If all ways lead to God then Jesus is a liar. He said: I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me (John 14:6). There is a definite article there. He is the way, not a way.
If you believe all ways get you to God then that includes One, Jesus Christ, who stated that this was not so. Remember Jesus said He is the only way to God.
So if all ways lead to God you must conclude that Jesus is a liar and surely no liar can be trusted to get you to God.
The only legitimate responses to this conundrum are these:
- Either all ways lead to God except Christianity because that religion is led by Jesus who is a liar.
- Or Jesus is the only way to God, as He said, and no other so-called way can get you to God
Either way you must stop and think. To say “all ways lead to God” is just not tenable.